Dillon Shane Webb was driving through Lake City, Florida, when a sheriff’s deputy spotted a decal on his rear window: “I EAT ASS.” The deputy called it obscene and claimed it violated the state’s disorderly conduct laws. Webb refused to remove or alter the sticker, calmly insisting he had a First Amendment right to display it. Moments later, he was arrested, his car searched, and he was taken to jail over a joke a court would likely deem protected speech.

Within days, the charges were dropped and the sheriff’s office quietly backed away. But the damage was done: a night in jail, a mugshot, and a chilling message about who decides what’s “acceptable” speech. Webb later sued, arguing that no officer should have the power to punish expression simply because it offends. His case became a sharp, uncomfortable snapshot of America’s ongoing struggle over where free speech ends—and government overreach begins.